| | |
1 |
Israel’s border with Syria is its quietest border |
Since 1974, there have been very few occasions in which we witnessed an exchange of fire on the Golan front. Syria has been completely deterred, and will never move a single soldier into now-Israeli soil. Why then should Israel give up land to a weak neighbour?
|
|
| |
1 |
What was taken by force can only be regained by force |
Israel only understands force. Its army withdrew from Lebanon (Twice) because it could not defeat Hizbollah. We should opt for resistance even if it will take many more years before we can liberate our land. Israel will eventually understand it can not continue to hold to the occupied Arab lands by force.
|
|
|
2 |
The Golan Heights are strategically valuable to Israel |
With the Golan Heights under its control, Syria will be able to resume shelling northern Israel and Israel will lose the ability to monitor and detect potentially hostile Syrian army troop movements. Giving up the Golan Heights is risky. Israel can not afford to take that risk.
|
|
| |
2 |
Israel cannot survive without a conflict |
Israel is a country that must be continuously involved in war and conflict in order to sustain its standing in the Middle East. Peace and open trades/borders with its Arab neighbors will dilute Israel’s Jewish identity and cause it, in the long run, to dissolve in Middle East’s vast sea of religious and ethnic minorities. […]
|
|
|
3 |
Syria supports terrorism against Israel |
Syria’s relationship with Hezbollah and with Hamas goes well beyond a merely political one, and in fact includes financial and military support, which is later used against Israel. How can we make peace with a nation that says it wants peace, but at the same time supports terrorist organizations?
|
|
| |
|
4 |
Syria lost the Golan because it attacked Israel |
Israel captured the Golan Heights in 1967 because Syria attacked periodically or continuously Israeli settlements below the Heights, inside Israel. Syria and Egypt were planning to destroy Israel, and Israel was left with no choice but to preempt, and to capture this strategic territory. Israel later annexed it, and today it is a part of […]
|
|
| |
4 |
There is little evidence that Israel values peace |
Some statements and actions by the Israeli government stir the prolonged doubt of the Syrian and Arab world in Israel’s real motivations and sought goals for engaging in peace negotiations. An impetus for this doubt is the absence of any evidence that Israel realizes the tactical and strategic value of peace with Syria. This is […]
|
|
|
| |
|
6 |
Syria has not engaged in any trust-building actions |
Syria has not made any effort towards seeding a trust-building process. For instance, Syria had welcomed Mr. Azmi Bishara in 2001, whilst he was a member of the Israeli Knesset, yet despite the fact that there are other members of the Israeli Knesset of non-Arab descent, who are also pro peace with Syria, the Syrian […]
|
|
| |
6 |
Obama cannot pressure Israel, and Israel will not move without pressure |
It is evident by now that the Obama administration will not be able to risk confronting Israel`s powerful allies in the United States. So far, differences between the Middle East policies of the Bush and Obama administrations seem to be mostly stylistic in nature. Even if negotiations start, the United States will not be a […]
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
8 |
Israel is a “Crusaders’ outpost” |
Since the arrival of the Crusaders in the 11th century AD to the Levant, the West has never stopped dreaming of occupying and controlling the land of the Muslims. The West, after being defeated several times, has finally decided to use the Zionism cause (maybe even invented it) to plant its modern presence in the […]
|
|
|
| |
9 |
Israel is an immoral and illegitimate state that should never be recognized by anyone |
On March 13 2009, in a speech commemorating the Prophet Muhammad’s birthday, Hizbullah secretary-general Hasan Nasrallah had this to say about the prospect of recognizing Israel: “Today, and tomorrow, and after one year, and one hundred years, and one thousand years, until the Hour of Judgment, we and our children and our grandchildren and our […]
|
|
|
10 |
Syria only understands power |
Not long after the Turks moved forces to the Syrian front, did the Assad regime finally gave up Alexandretta (Hatay). Why shouldn’t they give up the Golan Heights, a much smaller piece of land and less inhabited?
|
|
| |
10 |
Israeli governments don’t last long enough to sign a peace agreement. |
The Arabs have been negotiating with successive Israeli governments since the Madrid conference in 1991. Each time negotiations neared a final agreement the Israeli government collapsed, new elections were called and a new government announced it will not accept all the understandings reach between the previous Israeli government and one of its Arab negotiating partners.
|
|
|
11 |
Syria does not have enough tangibles to offer in return for the Golan |
The main Israeli concerns are security, territory and water rights. It seems that in all three parameters a peace deal will not be favorable for Israel. Obviously Israel stands to lose territory and potentially also water rights from the deal. Israel has currently no security issues directly with Syria, so the only possible improvement could […]
|
|
| |
11 |
Israel wants Syria’s submission |
Even if Israel accepts to return the Golan Heights, Israel won’t abandon its nuclear weapons which clearly threaten Syria and the Arab world. Israel, despite being the aggressor, will refuse to put listening posts inside its territory to forewarn Syrians of future Israeli attacks. The aggressor expects, on the other hand, the victim to allow […]
|
|
|
12 |
Israel cannot take a chance with Syria on the water issue |
Water is one of the scarcest resources in Israel. It is one of the most sensitive issues for all Israelis. Israelis believe Syria has tried in the past to alter and affect the flow of water to Israel. Syrian access to the Lake of Gallilee opens up still-fresh wounds. So is the thought of Syrian […]
|
|
| |
12 |
Israel consistently lets down moderate Arab leaders |
Arab leaders, such as Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who took serious conciliatory steps to recognize Israel’s concerns, did not get anything tangible from Israel in return. consequently he, like others before him, is now perceived by most Arabs as a weakling.
|
|
|
13 |
Syria’s regime is not actually interested in peace |
The Baathist regime survives on perpetuating a state of emergency through its “war” with Israel. Ending the war will remove the state of emergency and threaten the regime’s legitimacy, especially in the eyes of Syria’s strongly pro-Arab nationalism Sunni population.
|
|
| |
|
| |
14 |
No peace can be made until Israel ends its occupation of Palestine |
The Israelis have always sought to divide the Arab world, and to separate tracks while never intending to leave the Palestinian Territories. Syria should not fall for this trap, as Egypt and Jordan have in the past. Israel must first prove it is ready to end its Occupation of ALL Arab land, not only the […]
|
|
|
15 |
No intifada is expected on the Golan |
Unlike the situation in the Palestinian territories, the Druz inhabitants of the Golan live in Peace with Israel. Most of them commute to the Israeli cities and villages, live their life peacefully with the Israeli authorities, and would never revolt against the Israeli army, in which many of their Druz brothers from within Israel serve. […]
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
17 |
There is an imbalance between Israel and Syria’s regional power and global support |
The Israeli regional power, mainly in military and economic sense, is not matched by the Syrian one. Meanwhile, the total support by dominant world powers to Israel is also biased toward Israel. Thus, at the moment at least, it appears that peace negotiations with Israel will put Syria more in the position of a surrendering […]
|
|
|
18 |
Bashar Assad is a weak leader |
The current leader of Syria belongs to a small minority (Alawite) and does not represent the majority in Syria. He is a weak leader, not courageous enough (like his father was), and is not decisive enough.
|
|
| |
|
19 |
Historically speaking, the Golan is more Israeli than Syrian |
The Golan contains numerous Jewish landmarks which are about 2,000 years old. The Golan featured prominently in the Jewish struggle for independence against the Romans. The international border between the English and French mandate was set arbitrarily between these two world power in the case of Syria and Palestine (later Israel) as much as it […]
|
|
| |
|
20 |
Syria continues to interfere in Lebanon |
Syria has always interfered in the affairs of the sovereign state of Lebanon. It has occupied Lebanon for decades, and has advanced its own financial and political interests as occupier. Syria uses Lebanon, to this day, as a proxy in its ongoing battle with Israel. It has always interfered in the political makeup of Lebanon, […]
|
|
| |
20 |
It is impossible to satisfy all segments of Israeli society |
Many Israelis oppose paying the price for peace with Syria, the full return of the Golan Heights, because they feel that Syria poses too much of a threat to be trusted with its control of the strategic Golan Heights. On the other hand, many other Israelis do not support a peaceful settlement with Syria because […]
|
|
|